糖心传媒

Skip to main content
Research

Robots in the Kitchen: Philosophy Faculty Host Vatican Workshop on Emerging Tech

In a kitchen, a robotic arm with a glowing sensor eye prepares to scoop flour out of a jar into a bowl.
Written By Larry Pe帽a

Picture this: You鈥檙e waiting excitedly for a table at your town鈥檚 hottest pop-up restaurant, eager to try a famous specialty created by a Michelin-starred celebrity chef. Only you don鈥檛 have to travel to her fine-dining restaurant in Europe. She鈥檚 licensed her recipe 鈥斺�痠n fact, every intricate step in her cooking process 鈥斺�痶o a service that has trained a fleet of robot cooks to flawlessly replicate her precise movements. You鈥檙e about to enjoy a dish made famous half a world away, in your own hometown, at a fraction of the price 鈥� but it鈥檚 prepared by a robot. 

The technology in this imagined scenario is not far off. What will we have gained in this future? And just as importantly, what will we have lost? 

In May, philosophy professors Patrick Lin and Daniel Story, religious studies professor Anya Foxen and psychology professor Jennifer Jipson will travel to Rome to discuss these questions and many more at an interdisciplinary workshop hosted by the Vatican. The faculty team will meet with scientists, industry experts, religious leaders and philosophers from around the world to discuss the ethical impacts of automation and artificial intelligence on how our food is made. 

It鈥檚 part of a by 糖心传媒鈥檚 Ethics + Emerging Sciences study group, funded by a grant from the National Science Foundation, to examine the ethical implications of robotic and AI applications in the kitchen. The project involves input from faculty from around 糖心传媒, including food science, psychology, religious studies and gender studies professors. 

鈥淭his is our most interdisciplinary project, which isn't a surprise because the subject, food itself, touches on just about every single discipline at 糖心传媒,鈥� said Lin. 

While automation has long had a place in many aspects of the food industry, this project is focused on cutting-edge and near-future developments in what the researchers call 鈥渢he last mile鈥� of the food value chain: menu development and meal preparation. 

Such technologies range from robotic arms programmed to perform one process, like flipping burgers or peeling avocados, to technologies capable of cooking an entire meal. They also include AI applications for creating new recipes and quantifying kitchen tasks and data to the most minute detail. 

Last fall, the study group published an article in  recapping the first stages of their research and outlining the stakes of the issue, which was reposted in high-profile publications around the world, including , and . 

鈥淥ur study seems very futuristic, but some of these technologies are already being adopted by restaurants,鈥� said Lin. 鈥淪o we want to imagine the future. What if this trend continues and it really takes off? What are the kinds of disruptions we can anticipate?鈥� 

On a kitchen countertop, a robotic arm holds a knife over a cluster of tomatoes.The potential benefits of this technology are easy to see: more labor efficiency for both home cooks and food-based businesses; less human error in food safety, reducing the incidence of foodborne illness; and less time spent in the kitchen that could be better spent with friends and family. 

There are even opportunities for personalized nutrition, currently only available to those who can afford a team of personal chefs and dietitians.  

In the near future, an average diner might be able to go to a restaurant and scan a personal code that would upload their individual set of dietary needs, prompting an automated kitchen to create a nutritionally perfect meal just for them. 

鈥淲e see potential for great benefits in the technology, but also potential for some serious and harmful disruptions 鈥� and we want to try to balance out the two,鈥� said Lin. 

A downside of greater efficiency, for example, is a potential loss of opportunity for human workers. Every dollar of labor saved by a food company represents a dollar not paid to an employee 鈥斺�痩ikely in key entry-level jobs that often launch the careers of students, immigrants or single parents. What happens to your teen鈥檚 workplace skills when what might have been their first restaurant or coffee shop job goes instead to an automated kiosk? 

鈥淔ood service isn鈥檛 just a popular job 鈥斺�痠t鈥檚 a unique and valuable gateway into the economy,鈥� said Lin. 

Another ethical concern is a phenomenon called 鈥渞everse adaptation,鈥� in which interchangeable, unskilled human labor is used to facilitate an automated technological process, rather than the automated technology being used as a tool to assist a human objective. 

An example of this is CloudChef, a tech startup that seeks to, in its own words, 鈥渃odify the intuition of the chef.鈥�

Using AI technology, CloudChef records the process of a top chef preparing a signature dish, then breaks the process down into specific prompts to be followed by an employee who can then mass-produce the dish at a cheaper rate 鈥� without ever having to know how to cook. 

鈥淭his is the sort of model of labor that we often see in Amazon warehouses, because it's more efficient for laborers to be interchangeable,鈥� said Story. 鈥淭hat can be alienating and can make work miserable or boring or menial in a different way. And I think this is something we should seriously worry about.鈥� 

Another risk point involves surveillance. A key component of developing effective automated cooking technology is mountains of data 鈥斺�痺hich means precise monitoring of people who currently do that work. Many studies have shown that more supervision in the workplace leads to more dissatisfaction for the employees being watched. 

And it鈥檚 not just the food creators being watched. Diners taking advantage of automated food preparation might be generating tons of precise data about their eating habits. Who might want to purchase such information? What might happen if your employer or health insurance company could see a detailed list of everything you ate? 

We see potential for great benefits in the technology, but also potential for some serious and harmful disruptions 鈥� and we want to try to balance out the two.

Of key concern to the study is what happens to general quality of life if one of humankind鈥檚 most fundamental experiences becomes automated by technology. 

鈥淥ftentimes the value and pleasure we get out of eating food is inflected by our beliefs about how it's connected to community or our beliefs about who made it,鈥� said Story. 鈥淚f you're at a family dinner and your parents or grandparents made a meal, your experience of eating that food is going to be affected by your knowledge that this was made by someone who loves you in the context of this loving family event. Technological advancements might change the literal experience of eating and what you get out of your food.鈥� 

That concept extends beyond the family to a cultural level. 

鈥淭hink about your favorite cities and towns around the world,鈥� said Lin. 鈥淐hances are, you're also thinking about some of the restaurants, cafes or street food you鈥檝e had there. That is part of the experience of enjoying the character of a neighborhood or a culture. No one remembers a city because of the awesome robotic kiosk that they got a pizza from once.鈥� 

Lin and Story explore these questions because oftentimes, tech companies are too focused on what they can achieve to stop and wonder whether they should achieve it. Their work is meant to help tech companies, as well as policymakers and the public, more effectively evaluate the potential risks and rewards of new technology. 

Perhaps nowhere is that deliberation more important than in technology that affects our relationship with food. 

鈥淔ood is one of the most basic things to human life, next to air and water,鈥� said Lin. 鈥淭he kitchen has a special place in the home and in communities. We need to pay extra attention to that, because it has the potential to be much more disruptive to our society than other technologies.鈥奍t鈥檚 a deeply human subject and automating anything around that could have serious unknown effects.鈥�


Want more Learn by Doing stories in your life? Sign up for our monthly newsletter, the !

Tags
artificial intelligence